I crossed the enemy lines and used generative AI. But before you torch my ass, let me explain. I hardly had a choice.
My last paid commission was a year ago; I can barely afford my Adobe subscription. I’ve never in my life had a year that bad financially. So when Dribbble offered me a feature in their September article featuring the Branding Agencies with Original Brand Concepts my interest was piqued, to say the least.
But there was a caveat, I had to take part in the CapCut Studio contest and submit a branding project using CapCut’s 2.0 AI feature.
I was crushed when I got to this part. I felt angry and powerless. I was with my cat at the veterinary office, and I couldn’t contain the disappointment. I was furious and defeated at the same time. I thought to myself: So this is it. In order to survive I’ll have to use this tool that I know is shit, that I despise so much. I was ready to give up, right then and there.

And as I was waiting in line comforting my little precious Julka, fate smiled upon me and decided to gift me with the idea that’s as close to genius as I can get. By the way, for anyone who’s wondering, Julka is totally fine, there’s just always something with that cat.
I knew what I had to do next. I went through the terms and conditions of that contest like a hawk. First, I had to make sure I would absolutely have to use the AI feature in order to qualify.
Unfortunately, I did. But nowhere in there did it say that I had to praise it. And that, my friends, was my way in. Because as creative as I am, I’m also petty.
I knew I had the chance to maybe not beat the system but at least have a little dig at it from the inside.
There was one more thing that was making things difficult. Dribbble reached out to me with a deadline of 5 days. And that can only mean one thing. There were not enough entries, and they were desperate for people to join in. That should tell you something on its own. But that’s not the point, the point is I was going on my vacation in 3 days, which meant that I had only 2 days to make it happen. I was on the clock.
Lucky for me, I already had an entire idea in my head. Now I just had to lock in and execute it.
The contest requirements were to design a fictional product, as well as the entire branding for that product that included packaging and a campaign visual.
I knew I wouldn’t win, but that was not my aim. My aim was to enter in order to get featured in the article and possibly increase my exposure to paid clients. I’m not getting my hopes up, but I’ll take what I can get at this point. But also there was my chance to maybe get through with my message to someone outside of my bubble. The message? You might ask… surely it’s not that deep. Well, it is. At least to me.

You see, I’m not a fan of AI, to say the least, but I also know that I cannot shut it out completely if I want to stay in business or at least remain in the loop. So I watch it closely and stay open to the things that might be useful, if not now, then maybe in the near future. Despite every fibre of my being telling me to close it all up, shut it all down and move into the woods.
So here’s my opinion on the use of AI in the creative industry.
It’s crap. It’s wildly unpredictable. It’s addictive and should come with a warning, but it’s packaged as a tool that you need to use in order to stay relevant.
And when I see big names in our industry (I won’t say who, I’m not here to throw shade on fellow designers) desperately trying to justify the use of it in the creative process, it makes me want to cry. They know all too well how bad it is, and yet they swallow the bitter pill because they have bills to pay. And having morals doesn’t pay those bills.
Yes, it can give you that initial “wow” effect when you first use it. I surely felt it when it generated 3D packaging of my toy design. But it’s only at first glance and only surface-level. Because as soon as you try to correct one singular thing on a generated image you’ll realise that it’s nothing more than a very good, very advanced, very sophisticated and VERY well camouflaged game of roulette.
It’s nothing more than another gambling scheme, aimed at making you fully dependent and sucking you dry.
As of today, AI does not understand the context, so every time you ask for an amendment in your design, it will generate it from scratch, and you have no control over every minute decision it makes for you. Your role is reduced to determining if the result is passable enough in the end.
And if the AI companies couldn’t rub it in our faces enough, the truly “good stuff” is locked behind tokens that you have to spend in order to progress with your work. And before you know it, you are in too deep. Just like a gambling addict hoping that this time, maybe this time, you will finally hit the jackpot.
Except the jackpot is not some kind of a big payout, it is a barely passable piece of work that you would not accept from a human employee. But you deem it acceptable from AI because you’re out of tokens, out of patience or out of time.
Fuelled by rage and with all of the above in mind I got to work.
I picked up my sketchbook, and I must admit nothing fuels my creativity like frustration, so I quickly came up with an initial sketch. The more sass it had, the more steam I was able to let out. It almost felt therapeutic.

I spent the entire day vectorizing the art, which gave me the needed time to calm the fuck down and ponder the state of the world.

But it also left me with just one day to design the logo and visualise the packaging and create a campaign visual. Luckily for me I had all the components right under my nose. I chose the initials SM as the base for the logo (pun intended), I also took the poop (yes, poop) icon from reel symbols and added the one-armed bandit lever, it took me 20 minutes and I didn’t think twice about it.

Remember, my aim was not to win but to have enough material to enter the contest and not to get disqualified for being too sassy. I was walking a very thin line, but somehow I managed to stay on it. Notice the difference between the sketch and the final illustration, and you’ll know what I mean.
Then, finally, I couldn’t delay it any longer, I had to somehow use the damn AI and not lose my mind while at it. I asked it to generate a 3D toy based on my illustration. And at first glance, I was very impressed. Until I realised it made some executive decisions that I had to either accept or fix in post-production. Because why do you change the logotype colors without my instructions (admittedly, it looks better, but still I didn’t ask for that change) and WTF are those three-fingered thumbs-up icons repeated on each of the 6 buttons/handles thingies?

But I could work with it, except now I needed this toy in the box. Which was a way bigger challenge than I expected.
I uploaded the toy in 3D, the background illustration I’d made for the inside of the packaging and the written instructions for the rest, and this is what I got:

What the actual fuck! Thankfully, I was using the free tokens that were included in the demo, but if it had cost me real money I would be furious. So I went in and asked specifically to not invent the toy but use the one from the attachment. It got it right on the second attempt except this time it messed up the inside of the packaging that was correct the first time. On top of it the icons went through another round of quality and meaning loss. My free tokens were melting with each alteration and so was my patience. It felt like sitting in a boat that has a hole in it and when you finally manage to plug it, two new holes appear in other places.

I already had enough, so I decided to leave it as is knowing that it could only get worse from this point on. By the time I got into the campaign visual, I had lost my will to live. I just wanted it to be over.
However, with some free, unused tokens left I wanted to test the creative capabilities of the AI agent and I asked for a movie-like poster featuring my original illustration and the copy that I provided, leaving the creative freedom to AI. All in all, I wasn’t impressed, although the footer was funny, I’ll give it that.

Someone could argue that I didn’t give it a good enough prompt. But that’s exactly the problem. Because, you see, I am a visual artist. That means I am far better with images and translating my ideas into a visual form than I am with words.
It is not easier for me to bend over backwards and write a novel for AI to spit out something that could have been a simple PSD for me. It actually takes more time to formulate an idea into a written form than it would be for me to just do it in Photoshop. It’s like putting a pin into your corkboard with a Thor’s hammer. Technically, you could do it, but it doesn’t make sense!
I gave up and made the thing from scratch in Photoshop, it took me entire 5 minutes, 0 tokens and just a sip of water.

I’m not saying AI isn’t useful, it can be; I’m sure…

So far it’s exceptional at identifying every spider I find in my house and telling me if it’s time to move out. But that’s about it, and I wonder: is it just me who sees it? Or does everyone see it and just not care anymore?
I didn’t win the contest despite ranking quite high in views and likes. I’m not surprised. For one, I didn’t have much time to do a better job. I barely focused on the branding, which was the core part of the project. I used AI only because I had to and I didn’t want to pay for extra tokens to roll better results. Secondly, my idea and its case study were essentially mocking the software instead of promoting it. I achieved one thing tho, moral victory over the AI and its creators. A bittersweet one, but still.
I did get the feature in the post on Dribbble, which was the point of this entire debacle, but whether it will translate into landing a job is still to be determined. Until then, I’ll fight the uneven fight against AI, Tech Bros, recession and the algorithms.
If you want to support my work, you can do it in a few different ways. If life is treating you well and you have some coin to spare, hit up my Redbubble shop, where you can buy one of my prints or get yourself some decent t-shirts (very good quality, both, t-shirts and prints).
For a lot less you can get one of my digital Resist The Slop stickers on Etsy, I’ve uploaded them separately so you can spend only $2.89 to get the one you like.
You can also support my work for free by hitting TikTok or Instagram and liking the shit out of my stuff. I never thought I would ask people for likes, shares and comments, but here we are. It truly helps a lot and lets the algorithm know that my work is worth showing to new people.
And with that said. I’m signing off till the next rant.
Agata The AI Slayer, First of Her Name, Queen of the Dark Jokes and Mistress of Disaster.
Sign up to receive exclusive freebies and stay up-to-date with our latest news. As a welcome gift, you'll receive the Good Idea Icon Set, which includes 65 hand-drawn vector elements inspired by creative ideas!
Sign up to receive exclusive freebies and stay up-to-date with our latest news. As a welcome gift, you'll receive the Good Idea Icon Set, which includes 65 hand-drawn vector elements inspired by creative ideas!